A
AccuScore
Today's EdgesAccuracySeason ForecastsArticlesGuideTools

Predictions

  • Today's edges
  • Season forecasts
  • Player props
  • First five innings
  • Teams
  • Players

The record

  • Prediction accuracy
  • Download the dataset
  • MLB betting trends
  • NFL betting trends
  • NFL line movement
  • NHL season predictions
  • NHL betting trends

Learn

  • How to read a pick
  • Betting glossary
  • EV calculator
  • Odds converter
  • Arbitrage calculator

AccuScore

  • About us
  • Articles
  • Plans
  • Responsible gaming

WARNING: Gambling can be addictive and lead to financial harm if not controlled. Treat gambling as a form of entertainment, not a way to make money. If you need support, please visit our Responsible Gaming Page or call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit 800gambler.org.

© 2026 Skillbet Ltd. All rights reserved.

How to use AccuScoreTermsPrivacyResponsible Gaming

AccuScore is operated by Skillbet Ltd., Company Reg. No. C76440, 10, Level 1, Lapsi Street, St. Julian’s STJ 1261, Malta.

← Today's Edges
NHL•Sat, Oct 17 • 1:00 AMSilver Edge
PIT

Pittsburgh Penguins

3-3

VS
COL

Colorado Avalanche

4-2

Win Probability

Moneyline

PIT

+186

34.9% win prob

EV -0.1%

Kalshi

Moneyline

COL

-170

65.1% win prob

EV +1.7%

Kalshi

Analysis

The Colorado Avalanche host Pittsburgh Penguins in a matchup the simulation clearly favors for the home side. Nathan MacKinnon carries a 74% chance of recording more than 0.5 points, while Erik Karlsson reaches that mark in 54% of outcomes—a gap that reflects Colorado's offensive depth advantage. The game turns on whether Pittsburgh can generate scoring support; Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin each project at just 41%, leaving the visitors dependent on secondary production. AccuScore's model has won 60% of similar games favoring the home side over 1928 graded matchups, a modest edge that reflects genuine but incomplete conviction. For the Penguins to pull the upset, their depth scorers will need to outperform their projections while Colorado's supporting cast underperforms.

Probability Explorer— drag to explore lines

Puck Line (-1.5/+1.5)PIT -1.5
6-0.5-7
PIT Cover
27.5%
no odds at this line
COL Cover
72.5%
no odds at this line
Total (Over/Under)O/U 6.5
0.56.7513
Over Cover
50.8%
no odds at this line
Under Cover
49.2%
no odds at this line

Player Props

COL PIT
Sort:

Odds Comparison

Moneyline

BookCOLEVPITEV
Kalshi ↗-170+1.7%+186-0.1%

Where to Bet

silver
COL ML+1.7% EV

Win probability: 65.1%

Kalshi
-170Bet →

NHL

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche Prediction, Odds & Live Score

Fri, Oct 16, 2026, 9:00 PM ET

AccuScore's simulation makes Colorado Avalanche 65% to beat Pittsburgh Penguins (35%).

Projection updated Oct 14, 7:35 AM ET

Who will win Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche?

AccuScore's simulation makes Colorado Avalanche the more likely winner at 65%. The projection updates as team news and prices move.

Will Colorado Avalanche beat Pittsburgh Penguins?

AccuScore's simulation gives Colorado Avalanche a 65% chance of beating Pittsburgh Penguins, against 35% for Pittsburgh Penguins. Colorado Avalanche are at home and favoured on these numbers.

Every Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche meeting →Pittsburgh Penguins predictions & record →Colorado Avalanche predictions & record →

Form, head-to-head and betting trends

How Pittsburgh Penguins and Colorado Avalanche come into this game: their latest results, every meeting on record and how each has fared against the betting market.

Recent form

Pittsburgh PenguinsLWLLL
  • Oct 13at Chicago BlackhawksL 3–5
  • Oct 10vs Dallas StarsW 2–1
  • Oct 9at Columbus Blue JacketsL 2–3
  • Oct 7at Washington CapitalsL 3–5
  • Oct 5vs Winnipeg JetsL 2–3

Pittsburgh Penguins have won 1 of their last 5 (L-W-L-L-L, most recent first).

Colorado AvalancheWLWLW
  • Oct 13at Dallas StarsW 3–2
  • Oct 10vs Toronto Maple LeafsL 3–6
  • Oct 8at Calgary FlamesW 7–3
  • Oct 7at Winnipeg JetsL 2–3
  • Oct 3vs St. Louis BluesW 6–1

Colorado Avalanche have won 3 of their last 5 (W-L-W-L-W, most recent first).

Head-to-head

The teams have met 16 times since 2011: Pittsburgh Penguins 9, Colorado Avalanche 7. The last meeting, on Apr 5, 2022, finished Colorado Avalanche 6, Pittsburgh Penguins 4.

  • Apr 5, 2022COL 6 – 4 PIT
  • Apr 2, 2022PIT 2 – 3 COL
  • Jan 10, 2020PIT 4 – 3 COL
  • Oct 16, 2019COL 2 – 3 PIT
  • Dec 4, 2018COL 3 – 6 PIT
Every Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado Avalanche meeting →

Betting trends

Pittsburgh Penguins are 373-236 as favourite and 99-110 as underdog, and 210-205 on the road (51% of 415 games, 2011–2022).

Colorado Avalanche are 234-138 as favourite and 175-243 as underdog, and 227-173 at home (57% of 400 games, 2011–2022).

RecordPITCOL
As favourite373-236234-138
As underdog99-110175-243
At home273-146227-173
On the road210-205185-217

Straight-up records from AccuScore's game archive. Favourite and underdog are the market's, decided by the moneyline. How the NHL odds have moved →