The Indianapolis Colts released Daniel Jones on Friday, a day after a 26-3 loss at Houston, and coach Shane Steichen has named Anthony Richardson Sr. the starter for the rest of the season. AccuScore ran the Colts' remaining schedule 50,000 times with each quarterback, holding everything else — results so far, the schedule, the other 31 teams — identical. The answer: the season outlook barely moves.
Next up is the New York Giants on 29 November. With Jones at quarterback, AccuScore's simulation projects the Colts as 5.5-point underdogs in that game; with Richardson, that widens to 7.6 points. Across the rest of the schedule, AccuScore has Indianapolis averaging a 6.08-point loss per game with Jones and an 8.22-point loss with Richardson — a swing of about 2.1 points a game in the simulation.
| With Daniel Jones | With Anthony Richardson | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Projected wins | 4.95 | 4.62 | -0.33 |
| Playoff | 0.2% | 0.1% | -0.1 pts |
| Division | 0% | 0% | none |
| Conference | 0% | 0% | none |
| Super Bowl | 0% | 0% | none |
In both versions, the AFC South race looks settled: the Jacksonville Jaguars sit at 96.5-96.7% to win the division and 99.1-99.2% for the playoffs regardless of which Colts quarterback plays, with the Houston Texans a distant second at roughly 31% playoff odds in either scenario. Indianapolis' own path stays effectively closed either way.
One caveat matters here: AccuScore rates each quarterback on what he's actually done this season. Jones's 2026 numbers — an NFL-leading 13 interceptions, a career-low 58.4% completion rate, 5.6 yards per attempt and a 29.1 QBR — are extensive. Richardson hasn't started a game in nearly two years, so his number in this simulation rests on much thinner recent evidence. If Richardson's play once he's back on the field looks different from his earlier NFL stints, this projection would need to move with it.
See the full season predictions and the Colts' team page for updates as the AccuScore model incorporates his actual starts.