AccuScore simulated the rest of the New England Patriots' season 50,000 times with each quarterback under center — everything else (schedule, results so far, the other 31 teams) held identical. The split is stark: with Drake Maye, the Patriots' playoff odds are 53.9%. With Tommy DeVito starting every remaining game, that number is 21.9%.
The trigger is Sunday's 35-10 loss to the Detroit Lions in Munich, where Maye was knocked out in the first quarter after a sack by Aidan Hutchinson. ESPN's Adam Schefter and Ian Rapoport report the Patriots fear a fractured ankle and that Maye could miss an extended period, possibly the rest of the season — a concern, not a confirmed diagnosis. Coach Mike Vrabel said he doesn't expect Maye back for Week 12 and doesn't anticipate adding a quarterback from outside the organization; DeVito has already replaced him, with rookie Behren Morton third on the depth chart.
New England is 5-5 and has its Week 11 bye before traveling to face the Los Angeles Chargers on November 29. AccuScore's expected margin for that game is +5.4 with Maye and -2.1 with DeVito — a swing from a projected win to a projected loss.
| With Maye | With DeVito | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Projected wins | 8.92 | 7.45 | -1.47 |
| Playoff | 53.9% | 21.9% | -32.0 pts |
| Division | 3.8% | 0.8% | -3.0 pts |
| Win conference | 2% | 1.1% | -0.9 pts |
| Win Super Bowl | 0.85% | 0.5% | -0.35 pts |
AccuScore's average expected margin per remaining game drops from +2.21 points with Maye to -5.24 with DeVito — a swing of 7.45 points per game. Buffalo's division odds climb from 96.2% with Maye in the lineup to 99.2% with DeVito.
The DeVito column assumes he starts every remaining game; an earlier Maye return would land the Patriots' odds somewhere between these two numbers. One caveat matters: AccuScore rates each quarterback on his play so far, and DeVito has far less recent game action than Maye, making his number the less certain of the two inputs. Full season projections are tracked on AccuScore's season predictions page.